American Lawn Mower Company
BLACK+DECKER Electric Push Lawn
When it comes to keeping your lawn neat and tidy without the hassle of gas, oil changes, or loud engines, corded electric mowers are a smart, eco-friendly choice. Two standout models on Amazon—the American Lawn Mower Company 50514 14″ 11-Amp Corded Electric Lawn Mower and the BLACK+DECKER Electric Push Lawn Mower, Corded, 13 Amp, 20-Inch Cutting Deck—offer reliable performance for homeowners with small to medium-sized yards. But which one is right for you?
This head-to-head comparison dives deep into power, design, usability, and real-world performance to help you make an informed decision. Whether you’re upgrading from an old reel mower or switching from gas, understanding the strengths and limitations of each model can save you time, money, and frustration. We’ll break down everything from motor strength and cutting width to ease of storage and long-term durability—so you can spend less time researching and more time enjoying your perfectly trimmed lawn.
In-Depth Look: American Lawn Mower Company
The American Lawn Mower Company model 50514 is a no-frills, straightforward corded electric mower designed for simplicity and reliability. With an 11-amp motor, it delivers solid cutting power—enough to handle typical suburban grass types, including fescue, Kentucky bluegrass, and ryegrass. While it doesn’t boast the highest amperage on the market, the motor is efficient and provides what many users describe as “gas-like performance” without the fumes or maintenance.
One of the biggest advantages of this mower is its compact size. At just 14 inches wide, it’s ideal for small yards, tight spaces, or navigating around garden beds and landscaping features. Its lightweight design makes it easy to maneuver, especially for seniors or those with limited strength. However, the smaller cutting width means you’ll need more passes to cover larger areas—something to consider if you have more than a quarter-acre lot.
Unfortunately, this model lacks several modern conveniences. There’s no tool-free height adjustment, no push-button start, and no grass collection bag. You’ll need to manually adjust the blade height (if possible) and rake or blow clippings after mowing. The absence of a folding handle also limits storage flexibility, making it less ideal for cramped garages or sheds.
Customer feedback is sparse, but the reviews that exist highlight its durability and ease of use. One user noted, “It’s simple, quiet, and gets the job done. Perfect for my tiny backyard.” Another mentioned, “No frills, but it cuts clean and hasn’t broken down yet.” These comments suggest that while the American Lawn Mower Company won’t win awards for innovation, it’s a dependable workhorse for basic lawn care.
Best for: Homeowners with small yards (under 1/4 acre), those on a tight budget, or anyone looking for a lightweight, no-nonsense mower that just works.
In-Depth Look: BLACK+DECKER Electric Push Lawn
The BLACK+DECKER Electric Push Lawn Mower steps up the game with a robust 13-amp motor and a generous 20-inch cutting deck—nearly 50% wider than the American model. This means fewer passes, faster mowing, and better efficiency on medium-sized lawns up to half an acre. The motor handles thick grass and overgrowth with ease, and the winged blade design improves cutting precision and helps direct clippings into the included collection bag.
One of the standout features is the tool-free height adjustment system. With a single lever, you can choose from six cutting heights ranging from 1.5 to 4 inches—perfect for adapting to seasonal growth or different grass types. The push-button start ensures reliable ignition every time, eliminating the pull-cord frustration common with older models.
Ergonomics are well thought out. The foam-padded handle provides a comfortable grip, even during longer sessions, and the lift handle makes transporting the mower a breeze. When it’s time to store, the folding handle allows the mower to collapse into a compact footprint—ideal for small sheds or garage corners.
However, not all feedback is glowing. Some users report durability issues over time. One reviewer shared, “The deflector door cracked within a year, and later the motor started smoking due to shaft misalignment.” This suggests potential quality control concerns, though others praise its performance and longevity, with one long-term user saying, “I had a previous B&D mower that lasted nearly 20 years—this one feels just as solid.”
The plastic deck keeps weight down and resists rust, but may not withstand heavy impacts as well as metal. Still, for most residential use, it’s more than adequate.
Best for: Homeowners with medium-sized yards, those who value convenience features like height adjustment and grass collection, and anyone upgrading from an older electric or gas mower.
Head-to-Head Comparison
Performance & Power
The BLACK+DECKER Electric Push Lawn holds a clear advantage here. Its 13-amp motor outperforms the American Lawn Mower Company’s 11-amp unit, especially in dense or overgrown grass. The wider 20-inch deck also means faster coverage—ideal if you’re mowing a 4,000 sq ft lot or larger.
Ease of Use
BLACK+DECKER wins again with push-button start, tool-free height adjustment, and a comfortable grip. The American model requires manual effort to start and lacks adjustable settings, making it less user-friendly for those with mobility issues or arthritis.
Storage & Portability
The folding handle on the BLACK+DECKER makes it far superior for storage. The American mower’s fixed handle takes up more space, which could be a dealbreaker in tight quarters.
Grass Management
Only the BLACK+DECKER includes a grass collection bag. If you dislike raking or prefer a cleaner finish, this is a major plus. The American model leaves clippings on the lawn, which can lead to thatch buildup if not managed.
Value for Money
The American Lawn Mower Company is more affordable upfront, but the BLACK+DECKER offers better long-term value with its advanced features and included accessories.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: Can these mowers handle slopes or uneven terrain?
A: The BLACK+DECKER Electric Push Lawn is better suited for gentle slopes due to its wider base and lighter weight. However, neither mower is designed for steep hills. For challenging terrain, consider a robot mower built for slopes.
Q: Do I need an extension cord, and how long should it be?
A: Yes—both are corded models. Use a heavy-duty outdoor extension cord (14-gauge or thicker) up to 100 feet. Longer cords may cause voltage drop, reducing power.
Q: Can I use these mowers in the rain?
A: No. Electric mowers should never be used on wet grass or in rainy conditions due to electrical hazards.
Q: Is the BLACK+DECKER worth the extra cost?
A: If you have a medium-sized yard and want convenience features like height adjustment and grass collection, yes. For tiny yards, the American model may suffice.
Q: How often should I sharpen the blades?
A: Sharpen blades at least once per mowing season—or more if you hit rocks or cut thick grass. Dull blades tear grass, leading to brown tips and disease.
Q: Can I mulch with these mowers?
A: The BLACK+DECKER’s winged blade helps with mulching, but neither model includes a dedicated mulching plug. For better mulching performance, check out our guide on mulching mowers vs leaf vacuums.
Final Verdict: Which One Should You Choose?
Choosing between the American Lawn Mower Company and the BLACK+DECKER Electric Push Lawn ultimately comes down to your yard size, budget, and how much convenience you value.
If you have a small yard, are on a tight budget, and don’t mind raking clippings, the American Lawn Mower Company is a reliable, no-nonsense option that gets the job done quietly and efficiently.
But if you’re ready to invest a bit more for faster mowing, better ergonomics, and modern features like height adjustment and grass collection, the BLACK+DECKER Electric Push Lawn is the clear winner. Despite some reports of long-term durability issues, its performance and user-friendly design make it a favorite among homeowners with medium-sized properties.
Still unsure? Both mowers offer excellent alternatives to gas-powered models—quiet, eco-friendly, and low-maintenance. Whether you go compact or feature-rich, you’re making a smart choice for your lawn and the planet.
Check Price: American Lawn Mower Company
Check Price: BLACK+DECKER Electric Push Lawn
